Work Text
James woke up to the familiar sensation of a tiny body crawling into bed with them. A messy head of dark hair peeked up over the covers, and soon enough, warm little hands were pressing against James’ cheek.“Daaaaaad,” Harry whined, voice still thick with sleep. “It’s morning.”James cracked an eye open and smirked. “Mornings don’t exist until I’ve had coffee, Prongslet.”Next to him, Regulus groaned and buried his face deeper into the pillow. “Five more minutes,” he muttered.Harry, completely unbothered, flopped dramatically onto his back in the middle of the bed. “But today is Freddy’s party!” he reminded them, kicking the blankets off with the energy of a child who had already completely woken up.That got James moving. He gasped and sat up. “That’s today? Why didn’t anyone tell me?”Harry giggled as James grabbed him and tickled his sides. “You knew, Daddy!”Regulus sighed and finally rolled onto his back, rubbing a hand over his face. “We’re going to need coffee before dealing with an entire house full of children.”James grinned, scooping Harry up as he climbed out of bed. “Then coffee it is.”The morning was its usual whirlwind of chaos. Breakfast was a mix of eggs, toast, and animated chatter about what games Harry and Freddy were going to play.“There’s gonna be cake,” Harry said, swinging his legs under the table. “And a bouncy castle! And Uncle Siri says we can stay up really late.”Regulus gave James a knowing look. “Of course he did.”James just chuckled. “And what does Uncle Remus say about that?”Harry made a thoughtful face, then shrugged. “He said we’ll see. But he also said there will be a treasure hunt! And presents. And—”“Harry,” Regulus interrupted gently, reaching over to wipe some jam off his cheek, “eat your breakfast, love.”Once they finished getting Harry dressed—after much debate over which outfit was the best for a party—it was time to head out.Sirius and Remus’s house was already buzzing with life when they arrived. Balloons were floating near the ceiling, and a colorful Happy Birthday, Freddy! banner was strung across the living room. The air smelled like chocolate cake and popcorn, and the sound of children laughing filled the space.Freddy, already in full party mode, ran straight into Harry the moment he saw him. “You’re here!”Harry beamed. “I told you I’d come!”Sirius, drink in hand, sauntered over to James and Regulus. “Ah, my two favorite idiots. Thought you’d drop him off and flee?”James smirked. “Tempting, but we decided to stick around. You did say there would be cake.”Regulus rolled his eyes, but Remus just sighed in long-suffering amusement. “Come on, let me get you both a drink before Sirius starts making bets on which kid will cause the first disaster.”The party was exactly as chaotic as expected. There were magical fireworks that Sirius definitely wasn’t supposed to be using indoors, a group of toddlers attempting to climb the furniture, and at one point, James caught Regulus using the Black family glare on a five-year-old who had tried to steal Harry’s cupcake.James couldn’t stop grinning.At some point in the afternoon, Dorcas and Marlene arrived with their newborn daughter, Lyra, bundled in a soft yellow blanket.James was chatting with Remus when he turned and saw Regulus holding her, a soft, completely unguarded expression on his face.And Merlin, something in James’s chest ached.He remembered when Harry had been that small, when he could hold him with just one arm, when those tiny fingers had curled around his thumb. He missed it. The quiet moments. The weight of a newborn against his chest. The sleepy coos and the first little smiles.Regulus, still cradling Lyra, looked up and met James’s gaze.You’re thinking about it too, James thought.Regulus gave him a small, knowing smile. Yeah. He was.As the party wound down, kids started getting drowsy, but Harry showed no signs of slowing down.“Do I have to go home?” he asked, rubbing his tired eyes. “Freddy says I can sleep in his room!”James chuckled. “I suppose you can have a sleepover.”“Really?!” Harry turned to Sirius. “Uncle Siri, Daddy says I can stay!”Sirius grinned. “Of course you can! We’ll have so much fun.”Regulus gave him a look. “He will be sleeping at a reasonable hour, right?”Remus, ever patient, patted Regulus’s shoulder. “I’ll handle it.”Sirius scoffed. “You say that like you don’t trust me.”Regulus just blinked.James laughed and kissed Harry’s forehead. “Alright, be good, Prongslet. Love you.”“Love you too, Daddy! Love you, Papa!”Regulus smoothed down his hair. “Sweet dreams, darling.”With that, Harry ran off after Freddy, and James and Regulus finally left, hand in hand.Back home, the house felt empty without Harry’s presence. It wasn’t a bad feeling, but it was… quiet. Different.Dinner was slow and relaxed, candlelight flickering across the table as they talked about the party, about Harry, and finally, about the thought that had been lingering between them all day.James pushed his plate aside. “So… I saw you with Lyra today.”Regulus tilted his head slightly. “And?”James hesitated. “And… I think I want another one.”Regulus was quiet for a moment, swirling the wine in his glass. Then, finally, he nodded. “I do too.”James exhaled, relief washing over him. “Yeah?”Regulus smiled, small but warm. “Yeah.”James reached for his hand, rubbing his thumb over Regulus’s knuckles. “Would you want to carry them?” he asked softly.Regulus’s breath hitched slightly, eyes flickering with something James couldn’t quite name. Then, his lips curled into a small, knowing smile. “I think I would.”Heat coiled low in James’s stomach.”If you say so black””Potter actually” regulus said with a smal smile on his lips, ” you’ll always act as a black tho” James said with so much love in his voice.His grip tightened just slightly, a shift in the air between them. He leaned in, pressing his lips to Regulus’s in a slow, deliberate kiss.It started soft, but when Regulus tugged at the collar of James’s shirt, pulling him closer, it turned into something more. Something hungry.James stood abruptly, pulling Regulus with him, their bodies pressing together.“Bedroom,” Regulus murmured against his lips.James didn’t need to be told twice.The rest of the night unfolded in hushed laughter, whispered dreams, and the warmth of tangled sheets, heated touches, and the promise of something more.And as James lay beside Regulus afterward, fingers tracing lazy patterns on his skin, he felt it settle deep in his bones—this was their home, their family, and soon, it would grow again.
----- CHAPTER BREAK -----
Part Two: A New ChapterRegulus stood in the bathroom, gripping the small white stick in his hands as if it might slip away. His breath came shallow, heart pounding against his ribs. The test rested on the counter, its answer moments away from changing everything.He wanted this—he knew he did. But knowing something in theory and standing on the edge of it in reality were two very different things.His phone buzzed against the sink, and he reached for it with slightly unsteady fingers. Sirius Black—FaceTime.With a deep breath, he answered.“Alright, Reggie,” Sirius greeted, his face appearing on the screen, smirking as usual. “Tell me again why you’re calling me for this instead of James?”Regulus rolled his eyes. “Because James is a menace and would be bouncing off the walls before I even got the result.”Sirius barked out a laugh. “Fair point. Have you checked?”Regulus glanced at the test but didn’t pick it up. “…No.”Sirius huffed. “Oh, for Merlin’s sake. Just look.”Regulus’ fingers twitched before he finally reached for the test. His breath caught.Two lines.Positive.His chest tightened, breath hitching. This was real.Sirius, watching his expression closely, leaned forward. “Well?”Regulus swallowed hard. “It’s positive.”Sirius let out a whoop, nearly knocking over whatever drink he had beside him. “Holy shit! You’re having another baby!”Regulus let out a breathless laugh, pressing a hand to his stomach.Sirius sobered slightly, voice softer. “You okay?”Regulus nodded slowly. “Yeah.” He exhaled. “Yeah, I’m happy.”—James was sprawled across the couch when Regulus got down stairs, a book balanced on his stomach and his glasses slightly askew. His head lifted as soon as the door clicked shut.“Hey, love,” James greeted, stretching. “How was your—” He stopped mid-sentence, eyes narrowing. “Wait. You have that face.”Regulus raised a brow. “That face?”“The face you make when you’re hiding something.” James sat up properly, now fully alert. “What is it?”Regulus bit the inside of his cheek, suddenly feeling uncharacteristically nervous. Slowly, he pulled the pregnancy test from his pocket and held it out.James’ eyes dropped to the test. His brain took a second to catch up.Then, he gasped.“Reg—” He shot up from the couch so fast the book tumbled to the floor. “Are you serious?”Regulus nodded, unable to fight the smile tugging at his lips. “Yeah.”James let out a choked noise, half-laugh, half-sob, before yanking Regulus into a crushing embrace.“We’re having a baby!” James practically shouted into his shoulder. Then he pulled back, cupping Regulus’ face in his hands, his eyes suspiciously glassy. “You—are you okay? Do you feel okay?”Regulus huffed. “I’m fine, James.”James’ hands dropped to Regulus’ stomach, his fingers ghosting over the fabric of his shirt, reverent. “There’s a baby in there.”Regulus smirked. “That is how pregnancy works, yes.”James let out a breathless laugh before pulling him into another kiss, full of warmth and excitement. When he pulled away, his grin was blinding.“I love you,” he murmured. “And I love our baby already.”Regulus melted, pressing his forehead against James’. “Me too.”—James and Regulus had gone over a hundred different ways to tell Harry. They wanted it to be special—something he’d always remember.In the end, they decided to keep it simple.One evening, after dinner, they curled up on the couch, Harry nestled between them with a blanket wrapped around his shoulders. The fireplace crackled softly, casting a warm glow over the room.James ruffled Harry’s messy black hair. “Hey, Prongslet, can we talk to you about something?”Harry looked up at him, his green eyes bright with curiosity. “Is it about the baby?”Regulus and James froze.“…What?” Regulus asked, blinking in shock.Harry shrugged. “I heard Uncle Sirius say something about you having a baby when he was talking to Uncle Remus.” He tilted his head. “So, are you?”James groaned. “Of course Sirius already spilled it.”Regulus rolled his eyes. “We should’ve known.”Harry sat up straighter, eyes wide. “So it’s true? You’re having a baby?”Regulus exhaled, smiling softly. “Yeah, love. You’re going to be a big brother.”For a moment, Harry just stared. Then, suddenly, his entire face lit up.“Really?!” he squeaked, bouncing on the couch. “Like, really really?!”James laughed, wrapping an arm around him. “Yes, really really.”Harry turned to Regulus, practically vibrating with excitement. “Is the baby in your tummy right now?”Regulus nodded. “They are.”Harry gasped, then immediately pressed his small hands against Regulus’ stomach, eyes shining with wonder. “Can I feel them?”James chuckled. “It’s a bit too early for that, bud. The baby’s still really small.”Harry frowned in thought. “Well… when can I feel them?”“In a few months,” Regulus said, amusement lacing his voice.Harry huffed, clearly impatient, but then his excitement returned full force. “I’m gonna teach them everything! Like how to fly on a broom, and how to prank Uncle Sirius, and—oh! I’ll share my toys! Well… some of them.”Regulus smirked. “Very generous of you.”Harry turned to James, practically bouncing. “Do you know if it’s a boy or a girl?”James shook his head. “Not yet, but we’ll find out soon.”Harry beamed. “I don’t care which! Either way, I’ll be the best big brother ever!”James ruffled his hair again. “We know you will, Prongslet.”Regulus watched Harry with warmth in his chest. Seeing how excited he was—how genuinely happy—it made everything feel even more real.Harry suddenly stilled, looking serious. He turned to Regulus. “Papa, does having a baby make you sad?”Regulus blinked, caught off guard. “Why would it?”Harry hesitated. “Because sometimes you get sad about your body.”James inhaled sharply, but Regulus’ heart only softened.Trust Harry to notice everything.Regulus reached out, tucking a curl behind Harry’s ear. “You’re right,” he admitted gently. “Sometimes, it’s hard for me. But this…” He placed a hand over his stomach. “This is something I want. And it helps that I have you and Daddy with me.”Harry considered this, then nodded. “Okay.” He snuggled into Regulus’ side. “I’ll help take care of you. And the baby.”Regulus felt his throat tighten. He glanced at James, who looked equally emotional.Regulus pressed a kiss to Harry’s head. “That means a lot, love.”Harry grinned up at them. “This is gonna be so cool.”James laughed, pulling them both close. “It really is.”—At twenty weeks, they sat in a small, dimly lit exam room as the Healer waved her wand over Regulus’ belly. A soft, rhythmic thumping filled the air—steady and strong.“There’s your little one,” the Healer said warmly, adjusting the magical projection floating above them.James, gripping Regulus’ hand, looked about two seconds away from bursting into tears.“She’s strong,” the Healer continued with a smile. “And perfectly healthy.”Regulus blinked. “…She?”The Healer nodded. “You’re having a girl.”James gasped dramatically. “A girl?” He turned to Regulus, eyes wide with excitement. “Bambi, we’re having a daughter!”Regulus rolled his eyes fondly. “James, you cannot keep calling me that.”James ignored him completely, already talking to Regulus’ belly. “You hear that, little doe? You’re going to have the best big brother ever. And your dads? We’re going to spoil you rotten.”Regulus shook his head, but warmth spread in his chest as James pressed a kiss to his stomach, his voice full of love.—Pregnancy was strange. Beautiful, exhausting, frustrating, incredible.For Regulus, it was also complicated.His body had always been a battleground, a thing he had fought to claim as his own. Carrying a child was both empowering and unsettling. Some days, he felt strong—his body was capable of creating life, a miracle in itself. Other days, it was harder. Watching himself change, feeling the weight of dysphoria settle in his bones.James, of course, was an anchor through all of it.The first time Regulus hesitated before looking in the mirror, James had come up behind him, wrapped his arms around his waist, and whispered, “You’re still you. Always.”And Regulus believed him.—The pregnancy passed in a blur—kicks and cravings, late-night cuddles, James constantly talking to Regulus’ belly like their daughter could already understand him.And then, suddenly, she was here.Effy Pandora Potter was born on a crisp autumn morning, screaming her tiny lungs out the moment she entered the world.When Harry arrived at the hospital, clutching a stuffed stag in his arms, his eyes went wide at the sight of the tiny bundle in Regulus’ arms.“She’s so small,” Harry whispered in awe, climbing onto the hospital bed beside Regulus.Regulus smiled tiredly. “You want to hold her?”Harry nodded eagerly. James helped him settle, then gently placed Effy in his arms. Harry looked down at her with the softest expression Regulus had ever seen.“Hi, Effy,” Harry whispered. “I’m your big brother.”Effy yawned, tiny fingers twitching, and Harry beamed.James wrapped an arm around Regulus, pressing a kiss to his temple.Regulus exhaled, warmth blooming in his chest.Their family was complete.
----- CHAPTER BREAK -----
The Last GoodbyeThe letter arrived on a Wednesday.Regulus had been feeding Effy in the kitchen when the owl tapped against the window, its sharp beak rapping insistently against the glass. James, who had been rummaging through the cabinets in search of Harry’s favorite cereal, glanced over and frowned. “Expecting anything?”Regulus shook his head, gently wiping some mashed pumpkin from Effy’s chubby cheek. “No.”James crossed the room, unlatched the window, and took the letter from the owl’s leg. The parchment was thick, expensive. The Black family crest was pressed into the wax seal, dark and unmistakable.Regulus stilled.James hesitated before handing it over. “It’s from—”“I know who it’s from.”Effy made a soft sound, squirming slightly in her chair, and Regulus swallowed hard before reaching for the letter. His fingers were steady as he broke the seal, but James could see the tension in his shoulders, the way his throat bobbed as he unfolded the parchment.Silence stretched between them as Regulus’ eyes flicked over the elegant, precise script.Then, finally, he let out a slow breath and set the letter down.James waited.“She’s dying,” Regulus said, his voice even, almost detached. “She’s in St. Mungo’s. The Healers don’t think she has much time left.”James watched him carefully. “And she—”“She wants to see me,” Regulus finished.James leaned against the table, crossing his arms. “Do you want to go?”Regulus’ jaw tightened. His gaze flickered to Effy, then back to the letter. “I don’t know.”He had spent years trying to untangle himself from the weight of his mother’s expectations, from the cruelty that had shaped his childhood. And yet, hearing that she was dying… it unsettled something inside him.James didn’t rush him. He let the silence settle, let Regulus process.Finally, Regulus exhaled. “I’ll go.”The hospital room was quiet when he arrived.Walburga Black lay in a stark white bed, her once-sharp features hollowed by illness. Her dark hair, which had always been carefully styled, was streaked with gray and fell limp around her face. She looked smaller than he remembered. Weaker.But when she opened her eyes, her gaze was still as piercing as ever.“Regulus.”His name was a rasp on her lips, but it still carried the weight of a command.Regulus stepped forward, his hands tucked neatly behind his back. He had dressed carefully for this—robes pressed, posture straight. He would not let her see anything less than strength.“Mother.”She studied him for a long moment, her breathing uneven.“You came.”“You asked for me.”A slow, rattling exhale. “Yes.”Her gaze flickered down, scanning him with sharp precision. Regulus could see the exact moment she noticed. The broader line of his shoulders, the way he held himself. His voice, his stance. The undeniable difference.Her lips thinned. “So it’s true.”Regulus kept his expression blank. “If you mean the fact that I’m a man, then yes.”Walburga let out a weak scoff, something like distaste curling at the edges of her mouth. “And yet, you still call yourself my son.”Regulus didn’t flinch. “No. I call myself Regulus.”She exhaled through her nose, her gaze sharp despite the fatigue weighing down her features. “You are still a Black,” she murmured.Regulus lifted his chin. “No,” he said evenly. “I am a Potter.”Something flickered across her face—anger, perhaps, or something closer to disappointment. But she didn’t argue.Instead, she closed her eyes.“I should have done better by you,” she said, so softly he almost didn’t hear it.Regulus’ breath hitched.His mother had never apologized. Not once.And maybe this wasn’t an apology, not truly—but it was the closest he would ever get.For a moment, he considered saying something. A part of him, a younger part, still ached for an acknowledgment that would never truly come.But in the end, he only said, “Goodbye, Mother.”And then he walked away.Sirius was already at their house when Regulus returned.James had let him in, and he was pacing the living room, looking like he was about two seconds away from hexing something.“You went?” he snapped the second he saw Regulus.Regulus sighed, taking off his coat. “Yes.”Sirius scoffed, running a hand through his hair. “Unbelievable. Un-fucking-believable. After everything she did to us? To you?”Regulus remained calm. “She was dying.”“And?” Sirius snapped. “Did she suddenly decide to apologize? Did she beg for forgiveness?”Regulus hesitated. “She admitted she should have done better.”Sirius froze.Then he laughed, bitter and sharp. “Too little, too late.”Regulus exhaled. “I know.”Sirius shook his head. “And? What else did she say? Did she pretend she loved you? Did she—” He stopped, eyes narrowing slightly. “She noticed, didn’t she?”Regulus stiffened.Sirius swore under his breath. “What did she say?”Regulus hesitated, then exhaled sharply. “She called me a Black.”Sirius barked out a humorless laugh. “Oh, of course she did. That was supposed to fix everything, right?”Regulus swallowed. “I told her I wasn’t a Black.”Sirius tilted his head slightly, studying him. “And?”Regulus lifted his chin. “I told her I was a Potter.”Sirius let out a breath—something sharp and relieved all at once. Then, without another word, he crossed the room and pulled Regulus into a tight, almost desperate hug.Regulus stiffened for a moment before allowing himself to sink into it.“She doesn’t get to define you,” Sirius murmured against his shoulder. “She never did.”Regulus swallowed the lump in his throat. “I know.”Sirius pulled back slightly, looking at him with something softer in his gaze now. “You’re my family, alright? You, James, Harry, Effy—you’re mine.”Regulus let out a shaky breath. “I know,” he said again. And this time, he really meant it.
----- CHAPTER BREAK -----
ames’s alarm went off extra early that morning—almost too early for a man who was all too familiar with anxious overthinking. Today was their anniversary, and he was determined to make it perfect for Reg, even if his own mind tried to sabotage him at every turn.
He began the day with his usual gentle hustle. In the soft glow of dawn, James carefully dressed the children. Five-year-old Harry practically bounced with excitement at the thought of spending his day at daycare, while baby Effy, just one year old, gurgled contentedly in her stroller. After a playful breakfast and a few extra hugs, James drove them to daycare. At the bright, cheerful entrance, he knelt down to give each of them a loving goodbye.
“Have a great day, my little ones,” he murmured, planting kisses on their foreheads. As he watched them scamper into the caring arms of their teachers, a mix of pride and bittersweet longing filled him. With the children safely dropped off at daycare, he turned his attention to the rest of the day—starting with a promise he had made to himself: this anniversary dinner had to be perfect for Reg.
At work, James found it nearly impossible to concentrate. His thoughts were occupied with plans for the evening—a lovingly prepared meal that would evoke memories of their earliest days together. Finally, he made the decision to leave early. A quick apology to his colleagues and a promise to catch up later, and he was back home, ready to transform his nervous energy into something tangible.
Once in the quiet of their kitchen, the pressure of creating the “perfect” dinner began to mount. James pulled out his favorite cookbook and gathered the ingredients for Reg’s cherished dish—a fragrant herb chicken with a rich, velvety sauce. Every spice, every fresh herb had been chosen to tell their story. As he set to work, however, a familiar surge of anxiety crept in.
While stirring the simmering sauce, James’s mind drifted unexpectedly into a flashback—a memory as vivid as if it were happening right then.
________________________________________
Flashback – Hogwarts, Years Ago
It was his sixth year at Hogwarts—a time when magic should have outshone the darkness inside him. Yet, amid the enchanted corridors and flickering candlelight, James battled relentless inner demons. The castle, usually so full of life, echoed with the sound of his racing thoughts and the weight of despair.
One particularly bleak evening, as rain drummed relentlessly against the narrow common room window, James sat alone in a shadowed corner. His heart was heavy with insecurities he couldn’t quell. Just then, Regulus, a fifth-year student with an air of quiet determination, appeared. With gentle words and a firm, reassuring hand on his shoulder, Regulus said, “I know it hurts, James, but you’re not alone. There’s a spark in you that the darkness can’t extinguish.”
That simple act of kindness cut through the gloom. In that moment, amidst the soft murmur of the castle, their lives intertwined. Despite the storms of mental anguish, James began to trust Regulus—not only as a friend but as someone who would become his heart’s anchor. Even though life at Hogwarts was never easy, and the years that followed brought separation and heartache, their bond survived. When Regulus finally left Grimmauld Place a year after James had graduated—overcoming his own fears to return—their reunion became a testament to love’s resilience. In all its messy, imperfect glory, their love had carried them through the darkest times.
James Potter had never been good at silence.
He filled rooms with noise—laughter, jokes, the rhythmic tapping of his quill against a desk when he was bored. But this silence was different. It pressed against his ribs, heavy, suffocating. It had settled between him and Regulus like an unwanted ghost.
It hadn’t always been this way.
Their sixth year at Hogwarts had started like any other: Quidditch, detentions, James making a complete idiot of himself over Lily Evans. And then, somewhere in the whirlwind of it all, Regulus Black had appeared in his life like a star collapsing in on itself—bright, distant, and on the verge of burning out.
James hadn’t seen it coming.
One night, past curfew, he had climbed up to the Astronomy Tower to get away from the noise. It was one of the only places at Hogwarts that ever felt truly quiet. He hadn’t expected anyone else to be there, let alone Regulus Black—shoulders hunched against the cold, hands curled around the stone ledge like he was anchoring himself to it.
James had cleared his throat, expecting Regulus to sneer at him, to throw some scathing remark his way about Gryffindors sticking their noses where they didn’t belong. Instead, Regulus had turned to him, wide-eyed, like he hadn’t realized someone else was there.
He looked... lost.
James had always been reckless, and maybe that was why he stayed, leaning against the ledge next to him instead of leaving.
"You alright?" he had asked.
Regulus had scoffed, but it was weak, barely there. "Why do you care?"
James had shrugged. "Dunno. Just do."
It should have ended there. But somehow, it didn’t.
At first, it was small things. James found himself looking for Regulus in hallways, catching him lingering on the edges of conversations that weren’t meant for him. Then it was late nights in the Astronomy Tower, whispered conversations about things Regulus had never dared to say out loud.
And then came the moment that changed everything.
It had been past midnight when Regulus had shown up again, pale and breathless, looking like he had run all the way from the dungeons. He hadn’t spoken right away. He had just stood there, fists clenched, eyes dark and stormy.
"James," he had said, voice tight. "I—I can’t do this anymore."
James had frowned. "Can’t do what?"
Regulus had swallowed hard, his whole body tense like a bowstring pulled too tight. "This," he had whispered, gesturing vaguely at himself. At the way his robes never fit quite right, at the way he carried himself like he was waiting to be corrected. "I’m not— I’m not who they think I am."
James had blinked, mind sluggish. "Okay."
Regulus’ brow furrowed. "Okay?"
"Yeah," James said, rubbing his eyes. "So, who are you?"
Regulus had hesitated. And then, so quietly James almost didn’t hear it: "im a boy."
James had sat with that for a moment, let the weight of it settle between them. Then he had nodded, slow and steady. "Alright. Nice to meet you, whats your name?”
“regulus”
It hadn’t been an easy year, but James had been there. Teasing, supporting, standing between Regulus and the rest of the world when he needed to. Jeames help reg too cut his hair short and they learned spells to make it look like it was back to norma leght, when he had to go home over the brakes. Jeames help Regulus get a new uniform by begging minnie for 2 hours.
And somewhere along the way, between hushed conversations and stolen glances, between whispered names and lingering touches, James had fallen.
Hard.
One night, under the stars, Regulus had been rambling about constellations, about how his name was a star, how he had always hated that his family used the sky to name their children like they were meant to belong to something greater.
James hadn’t been listening. Not really.
Because Regulus' lips were slightly parted, his hands moving as he spoke, eyes bright in the moonlight, and James had thought—fuck, I want to kiss him.
So he had.
And Regulus had kissed him back.
It had been messy, a little desperate, a little like they were both trying to hold onto something neither of them fully understood. But it had also been right.
For the rest of that year, James had been his home.
But then seventh year came.
And everything fell apart.
________________________________________
James should have noticed it sooner—the way his mom’s health started reclining, her letters getting shorter and she wasn’t able to go his important games. James mental health started spiraling. He started pulling away, the way his hands fisted in his sleeves like he was trying to hold himself together. But James had been caught up in Head Boy duties, in his growing thing with Reg, in the war that loomed closer every day.
And then his mother died.
James didn’t cry at the funeral.
He had just stood there, staring at the casket, at the dark robes and murmured condolences, at the way his father looked like he had aged ten years overnight. His mother had been a force—stubborn, fierce, his biggest supporter. She had been the first to call him James, the first to tell him that he was exactly who he was meant to be.
And now she was gone.
Something in him cracked that day, but he didn’t let it show. He laughed with his friends, went to Quidditch practice, kissed Regulus when he was supposed to. He pretended to be fine.
He wasn’t.
Regulus knew.
He had cornered James one evening, standing outside the library as James lit a cigarette with a shaking hand.
"You’re not okay," Regulus had said.
James let out a humorless laugh. "No shit, Reggie."
Regulus frowned. "You won’t even look at me anymore."
James did look at him then. And for a second, something almost like guilt flickered across his face. Then, he shook his head.
"I can’t do this," he muttered.
Regulus’ stomach twisted. "Do what?"
James exhaled sharply. "This. Us. Pretending like everything is fine, when it’s not. We can’t even tell MY best friend YOUR brother about this "
Regulus went very, very still.’’
“I thought we agreed we would keep this between us secret to Sirius til it felt right”
James ran a hand through his hair, looking exhausted. "I don’t know how to be what the world needs me to be right now."
"I never asked you to be anything except you."
James looked away. "Maybe I don’t even know who that is anymore."
Regulus swallowed hard. "If you don’t want me here, just say so."
For a long moment, James was silent.
And then, softly—so softly Regulus almost didn’t hear it—James said, "Maybe I don’t."
It felt like getting the wind knocked out of him.
Regulus stared at him for a moment, waiting, hoping, begging for James to take it back.
He didn’t.
So Regulus turned and walked away.
And for the first time in his life, James Potter was truly, utterly alone. His best friend doesn’t trust him for lying and disappearing all the time and he just told boyfriend? Lover? Ex? Friend? To go away and his mom just died
________________________________________
But grief didn’t stay static.
A month passed. Then the whole year slipped through his fingers.
And on his last night at Hogwarts, James realized something.
He didn’t know what to do with himself anymore. Everything felt too heavy, too hollow.
So that night, he climbed the stairs to the Astronomy Tower.
And Regulus was there.
James swallowed hard. "I need you." His voice cracked. "Please, just—come with me. Leave that house. Time’s too short, I—" He inhaled sharply. "I don’t want to waste it anymore."
Regulus looked at him, silent, his expression unreadable.
“James, you know I can’t,” he finally whispered. “I have a name to uphold. A house to run.”
He looked so sad when he said it.
James’ chest ached. “Bambi, you can’t sit there and tell me it isn’t killing you.”
“No, I can’t,” Regulus sighed. “But Sirius got out, and they need their heir. There’s nothing I can do.”
James clenched his fists. “So you’re just going to walk around in those ridiculous dresses, marry some pure-blood prick, have a couple of miserable kids so they can end up just as trapped as you?”
Regulus flinched. Tears welled in his beautiful, storm-gray eyes. “That’s cruel, James.”
James exhaled sharply, his anger dissolving as quickly as it had flared. He reached out, his fingertips ghosting over Regulus’ wrist. “Please, baby. Come with me.”
Regulus bit his lip, shaking his head. “When, James? Now? You’re leaving tomorrow. You’re going to be a brilliant Auror—if that’s still what you want. You’re going to start your adult life, and I’m stuck here for another year. I can’t leave, even though I want to. Merlin, I want to.” His voice cracked, and suddenly, he was trembling. “But I won’t. And I can’t.”
He was rambling, crying, breaking in front of James.
At some point, he had stood up, his voice rising with each word.
James realized how close they were.
He could feel Regulus’ breath, warm and uneven against his lips. He could see every freckle, every tear-streaked curve of his face. And the only thing James could think was—
Why haven’t I kissed him in seven months?
So he did.
He kissed him.
He kissed Regulus.
And Regulus kissed him back.
It was desperate and aching, all their lost time pouring into a single moment.
And when it ended, they weren’t angry anymore.
They just looked at each other, breathing hard, as if neither of them knew what to say.
James swallowed. “Okay,” he murmured. “Yes, okay. But if you think I won’t be waiting for you, you’re wrong. Every day, all the time. I’ll be there, Reg. With open arms. Whenever—if—you want to come back to me.”
Regulus blinked rapidly, then nodded. “Okay, James.”
James took a shaky breath. He turned away, walking down the stairs of the Astronomy Tower, step by step, until he reached his dorm.
He crawled into bed, staring up at the canopy above him.
And for the first time in months, he let himself think—
Maybe, just maybe, I did enough.
________________________________________
Time didn’t stop.
Even though it felt like it should have, the world kept moving.
James Potter became an Auror. He had always known he wanted to fight, to do something that mattered. But he hadn’t expected the emptiness that followed him, the way success felt hollow when he had no one to share it with.
Sirius and Remus noticed.
“You’re miserable,” Sirius told him bluntly one night, sprawled across James’ couch, a bottle of firewhiskey dangling from his fingers.
James rolled his eyes, throwing a cushion at his head. “I am not miserable.”
Remus hummed, sipping his tea. “You haven’t gone on a single date since you left school.”
“So?”
“So,” Sirius drawled, smirking, “you should. You’re James bloody Potter. Half the wizarding world would kill for a date with you.”
James sighed. He knew what they were doing. They were trying to help. And maybe, deep down, he wanted to believe they were right.
So he tried.
He let Sirius drag him to bars, let Remus set him up on awkward double dates. He smiled, laughed, made conversation.
But every time he looked across the table, every time he leaned in for a kiss that didn’t mean anything, he thought—
They aren’t him.
None of them had Regulus’ sharp wit, his quiet intensity, the way he always smelled faintly of parchment and ink. None of them made James’ heart race just by looking at him.
So he stopped trying.
He buried himself in work, in duels and training and late nights spent chasing Death Eaters through dark alleyways. And slowly, the ache dulled.
He didn’t forget. But he learned how to live with it.
Until the night everything changed.
It had been a long day. James was exhausted, halfway to falling asleep on the couch when—
Knock. Knock.
Frowning, he pushed himself up, rubbing his eyes as he padded toward the door. It was nearly midnight. Who the hell—?
He pulled it open.
And his breath caught.
Regulus stood there, pale and rain-soaked, his dark curls clinging to his face. He looked thinner than James remembered, his sharp cheekbones more pronounced, his eyes heavy with exhaustion.
But it was him.
It was really him.
James opened his mouth, but no words came out.
Regulus swallowed hard, his hands clenched at his sides. “Do I—” He hesitated, voice barely above a whisper. “Do I still get to come back to you?”
James broke.
He didn’t think. Didn’t hesitate.
He pulled him in.
Regulus melted against him, burying his face in James’ shoulder. His whole body shook, and James just held him, gripping the back of his robes like he was afraid to let go.
Neither of them spoke.
They didn’t need to.
It wasn’t easy.
Regulus was haunted by the past, by the weight of his family’s expectations. His parents had tried to marry him off after Hogwarts, parading him around like a prized trophy. They needed an heir, a perfect, obedient son to restore the Black name.
But Regulus couldn’t do it.
He had tried—Merlin, he had tried.
But every time he imagined a life without James, a life spent in that house, in that cage, he felt like he was suffocating.
So he left.
He had nowhere else to go.
But James had promised—he had promised he’d wait.
And he had.
The first few weeks were hard. Regulus flinched at loud noises, woke up gasping from nightmares he wouldn’t talk about. James didn’t push. He just held him, let him breathe.
They took it slow.
Regulus learned how to live outside the Black family’s shadow, how to exist without looking over his shoulder. James learned that healing wasn’t linear, that some nights were worse than others.
But they tried.
And slowly, things got better.
________________________________________
James stood at the altar, adjusting his tie for the fifth time. His hands wouldn’t stop shaking.
Sirius smirked beside him. “Nervous, mate?”
James scowled. “Shut up.”
Remus chuckled. “You do look like you might pass out.”
James felt like he might. But then the doors opened—
And everything else faded.
Regulus stepped forward, dressed in deep midnight-blue robes, his dark curls neatly styled. He looked ethereal, his usual sharp edges softened by something James hadn’t seen in years.
Peace.
Happiness.
James’ breath hitched.
When Regulus reached him, he arched a brow, smirking slightly. “You’re staring.”
James huffed a laugh. “Can you blame me?”
Regulus rolled his eyes but squeezed James’ hands, his touch warm and steady.
And as they spoke their vows, as they kissed as husbands, James thought—
It had been worth it.
Every second. Every heartbreak.
Because in the end, Regulus had come home.
And James had been there, waiting.
________________________________________
The memory faded as the simmering sauce hissed under James’s careful stirring. His heart pounded as he realized the pressure was too much—he wanted everything to be perfect tonight. In his distraction, he’d allowed the dish to start to burn. A thin trail of smoke curled upward, and the rich aroma was replaced by a bitter, charred scent.
Panic surged. No, no, no… James muttered, frantically scrambling for a cloth and trying to salvage what he could. His hands trembled with both the rush of memory and the fear of failure. The thought of disappointing Reg, especially on a day meant to celebrate their journey together, sent his anxiety spiraling.
Just then, the front door creaked open. James thought he had more time reg was leaving the kids at James dad for the night. James’s heart stuttered as Reg stepped into the hallway, his presence immediately calming the frazzled edges of the moment. Reg’s eyes took in the slight chaos of the kitchen—a few wisps of smoke, a pan with its edges singed—and for a long heartbeat, neither spoke.
“James?” Reg asked softly, setting his bag down and moving closer with gentle concern. “What happened?”
James’s voice wavered as he admitted, “I was trying to make everything perfect for you, and…I lost track of time. I burned the food.”
Reg wrapped an arm around him and pressed a tender kiss to his temple. “It’s our anniversary, not a contest. I know you wanted everything to be perfect, but sometimes the perfect moment isn’t about flawless details—it’s about us, our journey, and all the imperfect steps that led here.”
In that moment, the years of struggle, the dark memories of lonely nights at Hogwarts, and the painful moments of self-doubt melted away in Reg’s warm embrace. Even if the dinner wasn’t flawless, the evening was theirs—filled with love, resilience, and the beauty of imperfection.
Together, they assessed the kitchen’s casualties. Reg suggested ordering a side dish from their favorite local eatery, while James, still flushed with embarrassment and relief, began to adjust the ruined sauce under Reg’s gentle guidance.
Later that evening, as the sun dipped below the horizon and the gentle laughter of their children—picked up from daycare—echoed through the house, James and Reg sat down at their small dining table. The dinner might have been a little overcooked and the plans slightly off-kilter, but every dish was imbued with love. Between soft smiles and shared glances, they celebrated not just an anniversary, but the entirety of their imperfect, beautiful journey together.
James’s heart finally eased as he realized that perfection wasn’t measured by a flawless meal or an untroubled mind—it was found in every step they had taken, every struggle overcome, and every moment they shared. And in that honest, imperfect dinner, their love shone brighter than any perfection could ever achieve.